Arizona's Republican Gov. Doug Ducey was re-elected Tuesday to a second term, beating Democrat underdog and education professor David Garcia in a race that focused heavily on border security and education.
Ducey, the Republican Governors Association and other backers spent more than $15 million for advertisements attacking Garcia as weak on border issues. They asserted he wanted to abolish the federal Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency — a claim denied by Garcia, who called for more humane treatment of immigrants, especially children.
The ads trumpeted Ducey's economic and border security accomplishments in Arizona, which has a 30 percent Latino population and some of the toughest state laws in the nation that target migrants in the U.S. illegally.
Ducey said he inherited a state with a $1 billion deficit and balanced the state budget without raising taxes and that he simplified the state tax code and cut regulations to generate jobs.
Garcia had hoped to become Arizona's second Latino governor after Raul Castro from 1975-1977. Garcia lost the governor's race after running unsuccessfully in 2014 for the post of state superintendent of public instruction, when Ducey won his first term as governor.
Education was a key gubernatorial race issue after an unprecedented statewide teacher strike in the spring shut down public schools for nearly a week as instructors demanded more funding. The teachers returned to class after Ducey signed a plan that granted pay raises that will reach 20 percent by 2020, including a 1 percent boost granted during the past budget year. The plan did not meet teacher demands for more money for school improvements and raises for other school employees.
Arizona voters were also deciding on races for secretary of state, attorney general, treasurer, school superintendent and two utility regulator posts. All statewide seats are currently held by Republicans, but Democrats hoped to win a few for the first time in a decade.
Bruce and Diana Husband, both 64-year-old retirees from Flagstaff, said they voted for Ducey and the rest of the Republican ticket because they wanted to ensure the U.S. isn't deadlocked over issues such as taxes, health care and immigration.
Bruce Husband said it would be unfair to let the caravan of asylum-seeking Central Americans into the U.S. while others apply through proper channels.
"My heart goes out to them, but we can't be the bleeding heart for the world," he said.
Polls showed the cash-strapped Garcia lagging in the race as the election neared, even though he was a strong supporter of the teacher's strike and said he wanted to increase state education funding, calling Ducey's education efforts "half measures and broken promises."
By mid-October, Garcia had raised only $2 million for his campaign, mostly in small individual contributions averaging about $50.
Ducey, who was born and raised in Toledo, Ohio, moved to Arizona to attend Arizona State University. Before entering politics, he was a businessman who led the Cold Stone Creamery ice cream parlor chain. He was elected state treasurer in 2010 and won the governor's race in 2014.
Garcia was raised in the Phoenix suburb of Mesa, served as a U.S. Army infantryman, graduated from Arizona State University and received masters and doctorate degrees from the University of Chicago. He worked for the Arizona Department of Education as a researcher and is a professor at Arizona State University.