Arizona Public Radio | Your Source for NPR News
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

Why NASA wants human guinea pigs to test out Martian living


Recently, NASA invited the public for a chance to go to Mars, or as close as you can get to Mars on Earth. NASA is seeking volunteers to test out living in the 1,700-square-foot habitat known as Mars Dune Alpha. The space agency is trying to determine as realistically as possible how living on Mars would affect humans. There are already four volunteer crew members living in that habitat. And they entered in June of last year, and they will emerge in July of this year. To talk about what it might be like for humans to make it to Mars, the real Mars, and stick it out, we called Kelly Weinersmith. She's a behavior ecologist and with her husband, Zach Weinersmith, the author of "A City On Mars: Can We Settle Space, Should We Settle Space, And Have We Really Thought This Through?" Welcome to ALL THINGS CONSIDERED.

KELLY WEINERSMITH: Thanks so much for having me on the show.

DETROW: The subtitle of your book kind of gives away just how hard it is, but let's just start with that. How hard would it be to survive on Mars? And what are some of the big examples that you came up with of just how challenging this would actually be?

WEINERSMITH: Yeah, it would be pretty hard. Mars might look sort of Earth-like from the photos, but it's got some really unique challenges, like its atmosphere is only 1% of the atmosphere that we have here on Earth. So you can't go outside with a spacesuit. So there'll be no, like, enjoying the feel of the breeze on your skin. You're going to need to suit up. And that also means that if your habitat ever depressurizes and you don't fix it fast enough, you would probably not make it through that experience.

We also don't really understand how Mars impacts the human body. So we've had humans orbiting Earth since the 1970s. We have had over 600 astronauts go to space, but the space stations are orbiting under the protection of Earth's magnetosphere. So they don't get exposed to the radiation that space has to offer, which differs from what we have here on Earth. So we actually don't know, for example, how much cancer risk would be increased in a place like Mars, which doesn't have a strong magnetosphere like we have on Earth and doesn't have a thick atmosphere to protect you.

Also, that sand on the surface of Mars, it's actually called regolith. It's sharp and jagged and sort of laden with endocrine-disrupting hormones, which will mess up your blood pressure and your heart rates. So you're going to want to make sure that you don't grow your plants directly in that or let that get into your habitat. And it's probably going to be cramped. Like, right now, it costs something like $300 to send just an apple to the International Space Station. It's going to cost way more to send it to Mars. And so you're going to have a pretty small habitat when you're initially starting out on Mars. So it's going to be cramped, and you better like the people you're stuck in there with.

DETROW: Why do you think they're such a draw then because this is a scientific goal not just at NASA, but at big, private companies like SpaceX? And more beyond that, it really seems like something embedded in our culture - this desire to get to the next big thing. I feel like there are a lot of people out there, including the people who have volunteered to be locked in a room at the Johnson Space Center for a year, who have dreamed about maybe going to Mars one day. Why do you think that is?

WEINERSMITH: I'm a sci fi geek. I totally get it. The idea of waking up on the surface of Mars and seeing a Martian sunrise sounds absolutely epic. I think that would be super cool. And so - but there are people who have other specific reasons for going, and it sort of depends on the community that you're talking to. So, for example, the rotating space station community, which these days is led by Jeff Bezos, who has a rocket company called Blue Origin - they argue that living in these rotating space stations is going to save the Earth because you can move people off-planet to these rotating space stations. That's going to reduce the pressure on the planet Earth.

And then they're - a lot of the Mars folks are excited about a chance to sort of start new governments and new ways of life, and a lot of them argue that, you know, Earth has become bureaucratic and wimpy. In going to Mars, we'd be able to start over again and sort of fix all the mistakes that we've made here on Earth. And that community tends to be led by Elon Musk, who owns SpaceX. And Musk is also particularly excited about having a backup for humanity. So the idea that if humans are multiplanetary, if something happens to the humans on Earth, there'll be a backup so humans can continue on even if something happens to Earth. So there's a lot of different reasons for wanting to go to space, a lot of different camps, but most - for me, I think it's mostly awesome.

DETROW: So do you think there's value in these continued studies that NASA is doing? Do you think there's more information to gather about what this is like? Or like you said, is the track record pretty clear, and we know what the challenges would be?

WEINERSMITH: You know, so I love NASA, and I love their exploration missions. And I never want to really be on the record saying that I am not pro something...

DETROW: But (laughter)...

WEINERSMITH: ...NASA's doing, but here I go. You know, so to me, the value of these analogs can be measured in what you change about your mission plan when the analog is done. So, for example, if at the very end they said, OK, we know that humans can't survive isolated and confined environments for nine months because they end up hating each other, so we're not going to go. Like, that would be a concrete thing. That's not going to happen here. And as far as I can tell, there's no specific piece of information they're going to get at the end of this one year or at the end of the three one-year stints that's going to specifically change something about a plan for going to Mars.

You know, we've had astronauts in space for more than 50 years. Surely, we can extract the data from what we know about what astronauts eat on the International Space Station. And this just seems like an incredibly expensive way to sort of validate that. And also, it's not even running for the full two years that you would need for a mission to Mars because Mars - because of orbital mechanics, it takes about two years - about six months to get there. You usually stay for about a year - that's, like, for most of the proposals - and then a six-month trip back. So, you know, for two years, you know, you're not even getting all the psychology information you'd need about how hard it is to live with four people for the whole length of time you'd need to be out there.


WEINERSMITH: So as far as I can tell, I'm not seeing the piece of information that's going to change our plans for going to Mars. Maybe I've missed it.

DETROW: Kelly Weinersmith is a behavioral ecologist and author. Her latest book, written with her husband, Zach, is "A City On Mars: Can We Settle Space, Should We Settle Space, And Have We Really Thought This Through?" Thank you so much.

WEINERSMITH: Thanks so much for having me. This was a lot of fun. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.

NPR transcripts are created on a rush deadline by an NPR contractor. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Accuracy and availability may vary. The authoritative record of NPR’s programming is the audio record.