As Uranium Mines Reopen, Controversy Surrounds the Grand Canyon Region

Nov 16, 2015

Nuclear power has gained more attention as a clean energy source. The raw material needed to make that power is uranium; and the highest-grade uranium deposits in the nation are near the Grand Canyon. The federal government has halted new uranium mining in the region, but old mines can still reopen.

Energy Fuels Resources owns Canyon mine on the Kaibab National Forest.
Credit Melissa Sevigny

The gate at Canyon Mine.
Credit Melissa Sevigny

Critics call them “zombie mines.” It’s just what it sounds like – they shut down, lay dormant for years, and rise back up again. Canyon mine is one of them. It’s located on the Kaibab National Forest, not far from the highway tourists take to visit the South Rim.

An aerial view of Canyon Mine.
Credit Google Earth

I’m standing in front of the locked gate. I can’t get any closer – the company cited safety reasons. Geologist Matt Germansen comes out to meet me. He points to a metal tower. Two wheels spin at the top. “That’s the mechanism that allows the buckets to carry the material from underground to the surface,” he says.

Right now that material is just waste dirt. The miners have dug a few hundred feet. They’ve got a lot further to go to hit uranium ore. “We’re heading down to somewhere around 1,200 feet,” Germansen says.

Canyon mine was partly dug in the 1980s, but it shut down in the early nineties when uranium prices dropped. A few months ago, the company that owns the mine started to dig again. Some are concerned about this renewed interest in uranium. Representatives of native nations spoke out against uranium mining at a recent press conference.

The headframe and warehouse at Canyon Mine.
Credit Melissa Sevigny

Scientists are testing the water quality at Owl Tank, close to Canyon mine. The metal plates bolted to the power poles have been there since the late eighties, when anti-mining activists destroyed the power lines supplying Canyon mine.
Credit Melissa Sevigny

Carletta Tilousi is a Tribal Council Member for the Havasupai, who live not far from Canyon mine. “We fear that our water will be contaminated and we can no longer consume the water. And it will lead to deaths and cancer, and affect all animal and human life,” Tilousi says.

Three years ago, the federal government put a 20-year ban on new uranium mines in the Grand Canyon area. Older mines, like Canyon, are exempt. The idea was to give scientists more time to investigate.

“From a scientific perspective, is there an impact that’s going to harm environment or harm people?” says Donald Bills, a hydrologist with the U.S. Geological Survey. “What evidence is there to support that impact? We’re still in the process of building a database that will provide that kind of evidence.”

Here’s what scientists know so far. The USGS found 18 springs in the Grand Canyon with too much uranium to safely drink. That’s about six percent of the sites analyzed. It’s often not clear if the pollution is natural seepage from rocks or related to mining activity.  Mines do have elevated concentrations of uranium, but it tends to not move very far.

Donn Pillmore holds a photograph of what Kanab North looked like when it was active.
Credit Melissa Sevigny

There are a lot of unanswered questions. Anne Mariah Tapp of The Grand Canyon Trust says any risk is too high. “We don’t know 100% what is going to happen with the groundwater in the Grand Canyon with regard to uranium mining,” Tapp says. “And because we don’t know, we should not threaten that precious resource until we have it figured out.”  

An aerial view of Kanab North.
Credit Google Earth

The Grand Canyon Trust wants activity at Canyon mine to halt until the U.S. Forest Service completes new environmental reviews. But for now, Canyon and other so-called “zombie” mines can operate under old permits.

Eventually, all of these mines must be reclaimed. Donn Pillmore gives me a tour of Kanab North, on the North Rim of the Grand Canyon, which is undergoing reclamation now. Pillmore works for Energy Fuels Resources, the Colorado-based company that owns Kanab North and Canyon mines.

The Hermit mine site, closed down in 1992 and now reclaimed.
Credit Melissa Sevigny

“At this time all of the contaminated material has been eliminated from the site,” he explains. “So what you’re looking at is the re-contoured mine site that’s just about ready for seeding.”

The Pigeon mine site, closed down in 1991 and now reclaimed.
Credit Melissa Sevigny

Desert shrubs will soon cover the site. Once Canyon mine is depleted, it’ll go through the same clean-up process. Pillmore says his company will then look toward other uranium claims made before the 20-year ban. He expects worldwide demand for nuclear power to rise. “So I think they’ll be a point when we see the price of uranium move up to where it needs to be for a lot of our operations to turn back on,” he says.

If that happens, Pillmore says the company might mine out all of their old claims before the ban on new mining is over. The mining industry wants to end the ban early, while critics hope to make it permanent.